Review

2026-02-22 23:07 - Checkpoint

Verdict: Minor Deviation Trigger: Phase boundary

Aligned:

• T-001, T-002, and T-004 align with Phase 1 scope and boundary rules (secrets via env, no plaintext credentials in repo).
• Task-level execution traceability and decision logging are consistent across completed entries.

Deviations:

• T-003 Worker alignment was partially deferred because Cloudflare Vite plugin conflicts with current DuckDB SSR externalization.
  • Resolution: deferred

Patterns:

• Strong security/config governance and clear defer-with-rationale behavior when runtime/tooling constraints appear.

Recommendations:

• Add explicit follow-up linkage for the T-003 deferral in later API/dashboard refactor tasks.
• Keep recording boundary checks in progress entries for upcoming auth enforcement tasks.

2026-02-22 23:31 - Checkpoint

Verdict: Minor Deviation Trigger: Session end

Aligned:

• Completed tasks T-005, T-008, T-009, T-010, T-011, and T-013 match plan scope and acceptance intent.
• Auth enforcement now exists at route-level and server-function boundaries for dashboard and slides.
• Dependency changes for T-009 and T-013 were documented with rationale in Progress.md.

Deviations:

• T-003 compatibility deferral remains open (Cloudflare Vite plugin vs current DuckDB SSR externalization).
  • Resolution: pending

Patterns:

• Strong traceability and secure-first implementation sequencing.

Recommendations:

• Keep verdict at minor deviation until T-006/T-007 close the T-003 deferral path.
• Define explicit closure criteria for the deferred dashboard Worker parity item.

2026-02-22 23:53 - Checkpoint

Verdict: Minor Deviation Trigger: Session end

Aligned:

• T-012 and Phase 4 workflows (T-014, T-015, T-016, T-017) were completed with matching acceptance outcomes.
• Dependency amendments were logged with rationale and kept append-only trace quality.
• T-006/T-007 were started in the correct direction (auth-protected API detail endpoints + loader migration for detail pages).

Deviations:

• T-006 remains partial: aggregate API endpoints are not implemented yet.
  • Resolution: pending
• T-007 remains partial: aggregate dashboard loaders still use direct local data paths.
  • Resolution: pending
• T-003 carry-over parity deferral remains open until T-006/T-007 closure.
  • Resolution: pending

Patterns:

• Infrastructure and deployment tracks are advancing faster than core data migration tracks.
• Security-first sequencing remains consistent.

Recommendations:

• Prioritize closing T-006 then T-007 before additional scope.
• Define explicit closure signal for the T-003 carry-over parity deferral.

2026-02-23 00:12 - Checkpoint

Verdict: Aligned Trigger: Milestone completion

Aligned:

• T-006 now provides API read coverage for all dashboard views (overview/revenue/orders/programs/schools/marketing + detail routes) with auth-gated access.
• T-007 now routes all protected dashboard loaders through API-backed server functions.
• Targeted validation for changed services passed (@services/api and @services/dashboard: typecheck, lint, build).
• T-003 carry-over parity deferral is now closed from the data-path perspective.

Deviations:

• None.

Patterns:

• Migration sequencing remained security-first while converging runtime reads into a single Turso-first API layer.

Recommendations:

• Continue with T-018 and T-019 next so deployment governance/docs stay in sync with implementation.

2026-02-23 00:16 - Checkpoint

Verdict: Aligned Trigger: Docs milestone

Aligned:

• T-018 now documents GitHub environments/secrets and production approval guidance across workflow deploy paths.
• T-019 now updates architecture + analytics docs to the current Worker runtime topology and Turso-first dashboard path.
• Slides auth + R2 delivery model is documented in architecture-level flow diagrams and deployment notes.

Deviations:

• None.

Patterns:

• Governance docs were updated in the same execution phase as runtime changes, preserving architecture/source-of-truth consistency.

Recommendations:

• Proceed with T-021 validation checklist.
• For T-020 (@plan/state.md), apply the session protocol: propose updates for approval before writing.

2026-02-23 00:18 - Checkpoint

Verdict: Aligned Trigger: Validation run

Aligned:

• Monorepo typecheck, test, and build checks were executed successfully.
• Lint exception was captured transparently (@core/ai pre-existing lint issues), satisfying "pass or documented exception" criteria for this checkpoint stage.

Deviations:

• None beyond already-documented lint baseline exception.

Patterns:

• Validation is being advanced incrementally while preserving explicit exception tracking.

Recommendations:

• Finish deployed environment smoke tests (dashboard/slides login + reports subpaths) to close T-021.

2026-02-23 00:33 - Checkpoint

Verdict: Aligned Trigger: T-021 closure

Aligned:

• Dashboard auth flow was verified in runtime (unauth redirect, login success, logout redirect).
• Slides auth and subpath contract were verified in runtime for /reports/{entity}/{period}/, /report.pdf, and /report.pptx after login.
• Previous quality-gate runs (typecheck/test/build, lint with documented baseline exception) remain valid for this checkpoint.

Deviations:

• Custom dev.* domains were not DNS-resolvable from the execution environment; smoke checks were executed against local dev ports instead.
  • Resolution: documented exception

Patterns:

• Validation checklist closure maintained explicit exception documentation without skipping behavioral verification.

Recommendations:

• Proceed with T-020 (@plan/state.md update proposal/approval flow).

2026-02-23 00:37 - Checkpoint

Verdict: Aligned Trigger: Plan closure checkpoint

Aligned:

• T-020 project state updates were applied and now reflect Plan 011 architecture/runtime decisions.
• All plan tasks are complete with append-only execution/review trace continuity.

Deviations:

• None.

Patterns:

• Governance docs, architecture docs, and runtime implementation are now synchronized in the same execution window.

Recommendations:

• Prepare final review/commit for Plan 011 artifact set.